US President Donald Trump’s efforts to secure additional conservative judges before Democrats regain control of the Senate are facing growing opposition from members of his own Republican Party.
During his second term, Senate Republicans had largely supported Trump’s judicial appointments, approving 57 nominees for lifetime positions on federal district and appeals courts. These appointments have helped strengthen conservative influence across the US judicial system, with consequences expected to continue long after his presidency.
However, the latest push to approve more nominees before the Senate’s political balance changes has exposed disagreements between the White House and several Republican lawmakers.
Some senators are objecting to candidates selected for judicial vacancies in their own states, arguing that their views should be considered during the nomination process.
Under a long-standing Senate tradition, senators from a nominee’s home state can influence whether a judicial candidate moves forward by submitting a document known as a blue slip. Without the required support, certain nominees can face difficulties advancing through the Senate Judiciary Committee.
Republican Senator Alan Armstrong of Oklahoma criticized the administration for overlooking candidates recommended by local senators and choosing its own preferred nominee instead.
The disagreements have also involved Senators Thom Tillis of North Carolina and John Cornyn of Texas, both members of the Senate Judiciary Committee who have raised concerns about some of Trump’s selections.
White House Changes Judicial Nomination
The dispute became particularly visible after the White House withdrew the nomination of US District Judge Lee Rudofsky for a position on the 8th US Circuit Court of Appeals.
The decision followed opposition from Arkansas Republican Senators John Boozman and Tom Cotton. The administration subsequently nominated Arkansas Supreme Court Justice J. Cody Hiland for the position.
Tillis has also criticized the White House for presenting judicial candidates to senators as final choices rather than consulting them during the selection process. He believes lawmakers should have a meaningful role in deciding who represents their states on federal courts.
Republicans Race to Confirm Remaining Nominees
Senate Majority Leader John Thune has identified judicial appointments as a major priority while Republicans still control the chamber.
The Senate has already approved its first judicial nominee during the current lame-duck session, while 23 other candidates remain awaiting confirmation. Among them is Colorado-based Judge Daniel Domenico, who has been nominated for a seat on the 10th US Circuit Court of Appeals.
However, the remaining nominations face uncertainty as some Republican senators prepare to leave office and are using their final weeks to challenge candidates they oppose.
Trump’s broader judicial campaign began during his first presidency, when he appointed 234 federal judges between 2017 and 2021. His appointments included three Supreme Court justices, helping establish the court’s current conservative majority.
Disagreements Over Candidates in Texas and Oklahoma
The conflict has also extended to judicial nominations in Texas and Oklahoma.
In Texas, Senator John Cornyn has not committed to supporting T. Elliot Gaiser, Trump’s choice for a federal judgeship in Dallas. Gaiser previously worked in the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel and was selected without following the traditional senator-led screening process in the state.
Cornyn’s lack of support could prevent Gaiser from moving forward to a Judiciary Committee hearing.
In Oklahoma, Senator Alan Armstrong has withdrawn his earlier support for Zach West, a lawyer who works in the state attorney general’s office. West has received backing from conservative legal groups for his positions on abortion restrictions and religious schools.
Thom Tillis has supported Armstrong’s opposition, making West’s confirmation prospects more uncertain.
Armstrong is scheduled to leave the Senate on November 30, after which newly elected Republican Senator Kevin Hern will take his place. His position on West’s nomination could potentially differ from Armstrong’s.
Tillis has indicated that he will continue opposing the nomination until he receives a clear request from the relevant senators to move forward.
The growing disagreements highlight divisions within the Republican Party over judicial appointments, as Trump seeks to strengthen conservative influence in the federal courts before the Senate’s political control changes.